Saturday, February 14, 2009

Re: 21st Century Computer Skills

As always, the discussion here is fascinating and it seems led by people
working with middle and high school students. I'd love to know what
elementary teachers think in these discussions. The loftier the language
and goals stated, the more I think the speaker is forgetting some basic
steps in a student's learning about computers that occur prior to high
school. I wonder what fundamental concepts and mental structures need to
be built (and skills developed) before students can be the adaptable 21st
century learners described in this discussion.

Young children think concretely and sometimes grasp the whole better when
it is broken down into parts. Yes, my school still teaches word
processing in a stand alone fashion (and keyboarding and other discrete
skills), not as much as we used to, but without this emphasis on writing
by itself, the written component of a multimedia presentation is weakened.
Students rush towards graphics, audio, and video while building web
pages. They jot off hasty, ill-considered responses on blogs. Sticking
with language in a word processor helps them learn to focus on ideas and
content first. This year I halted a multimedia web publishing project,
sent every fourth grader back to Word to refine their thinking and
language, then returned to creating and publishing multimedia web pages
using iWeb after they reached an acceptable level of clarity in their text
comments. Our time spent in Word included lots of editing and formatting
work that yielded presentable print documents. I can't imagine word
processors going away anytime soon.

In response to comments about the five-step user, I also feel in early
learning about computers there is a lot of pressure to provide handouts,
even though these end up being single-use documents. Young children need
lots of support and clearly identified small, manageable steps. Sometimes
this looks like instruction focused just on skills, and sometimes it is
mini-lessons to move along a bigger project.

Students as young as first grade already fit the contrasting profiles of
five step users wanting manuals and those who adapt to feedback while
using a computer. Some students who start out as five-step users soon
gain the confidence and proficiency to work well with less external
support, but some never do in the six years that I teach them. I don't
expect that every young student has a strong built-in technology instinct
or intelligence, and I hope there are opportunities in the future for
those who don't shine with technology. All of these children have gifts,
talents, and strengths of one kind or another.

Greg Stevens
Lower School Coordinator of Instructional Technology
MICDS
St. Louis, MO


[ For info on ISED-L see http://www.gds.org/ISED-L ]
Submissions to ISED-L are released under a creative commons, attribution, non-commercial, share-alike license.
RSS Feed, http://listserv.syr.edu/scripts/wa.exe?RSS&L=ISED-L